Friday, May 18, 2007

Class Blog Discussion

Well, we had our class blog discussion today. Overall I think it went well, the kids definitely seemed to enjoy it. The responses to the topics ranged from insightful and profound to completely inane and totally random. Luckily I have my rubric so that I can give credit to those kids who took it seriously and did a great job (which was the vast majority of them).

Grading this is going to be interesting, but I have a system worked out. I am going to have a rubric printed for each student and as I go through the discussions I'll be adding points and taking them away in the relevant categories based on the quality of the comments they make in each post. Then I'll be able to give each student credit relative to the quality of their contribution to our discussion. Focus will be on quality as opposed to quantity; quality will be defined by the rubric they created. It'll take some time, but not any more time than reading and grading a stack of essays.

One other thing that I think is cool. There were four kids gone today, but unlike most class discussion days they don't have to miss out on what we did. I can just give them the web url and they can read the discussion and post their responses when they get back. Yet another benefit of this forum.

By the way, I've linked the discusssion page above and I'll do it again here if you'd like to take a look for yourself and let me know what you think.

2 comments:

Natalie said...

Jason,I'm so glad you added the link to your student blog - honestly I was totally confused as to what you were doing until I had the chance to see it in progress. I would bet that students would get better at blogging once they understand the logistics of the online format. This type of discussion DEFINATELY takes some rethinking. Lag times and intervening comments make for a new approach. But, in a world in which the WWW is a reality I would guess this is a good skill to learn.

The rubric makes more sense now - but the brevity of some of the responses makes me curious to see how grading proceeds. One thing that would be helpful for me as you begin to present your research is a running conversation of a single student showing the grading points that were assigned with each entry.

Great work!

respo said...

Okay - I am still confused (but it doesn't take much these days!) I get the blog which is very cool BTW. I don't understand exactly how you work the rubric part.

Maybe you can email me or explain when we meet in class. It sounds useful, but I am not sure how it works :)